Read our latest qathet Climate Alliance newsletters here.

Why does science denial remain widespread?

The scientific consensus is overwhelming: climate change is real and human activity–especially burning fossil fuels–is driving it.

So why does climate science denial remain widespread? How can misinformation that delays adequate climate action be challenged?

Those questions anchored a March 21 public presentation sponsored by qathet Climate Alliance. Two guest speakers offered complementary perspectives on the roots of climate denialism and how to counteract it.

This article is by Bob Hackett and was published as a Climate Crossroads column in the PR Peak. You can find it, and all the older Climate Crossroads columns, here.

Blair Weber, who researches misinformation during wildfire emergencies in the Okanagan, argued that climate denial has become intertwined with identity, especially in politically conservative communities where people may feel economically neglected or culturally dismissed. In such settings, denialism can become a marker of belonging and resistance to perceived arrogant urban elites.

Weber also emphasized declining trust in public institutions. During wildfire emergencies, some residents have refused evacuation orders or even confronted firefighters. While media and officials often framed such behaviour as irrational, Weber argued that authorities themselves sometimes contribute to distrust through inadequate or misleading communication. Residents who felt ignored or managed rather than heard became more vulnerable to narratives portraying institutions as engaged in coordinated wrongdoing.

As a response, Weber recommended deeper community conversations: listening carefully to local experiences and building trust through exchanging stories rather than correcting facts.

But Weber also noted that organized disinformation campaigns are real. The fossil fuel industry has spent decades funding efforts to manufacture doubt about climate science, using tactics pioneered by Big Tobacco.

That theme was expanded by Jennifer Nathan, a science educator and climate advocate who traced connections among fossil fuel interests, politicians, media outlets and fake grassroots organizations. Organized denialism circulates its talking points through podcasts, YouTube shows, conferences, tweets, books, “educational” materials, misleading publications that mimic legitimate scientific reports and think tanks such as the Heartland Institute, Fraser Institute and Friends of Science.

Of particular concern, with municipal elections approaching, is KIKLEI: Kicking International Council out of Local Environmental Initiatives. It pressures Canadian local governments to abandon climate initiatives as wasteful, even though the Insurance Bureau estimates that billions are needed to climate-protect Canada’s municipal infrastructure.

Nathan argued that disinformation must be counteracted directly by exposing the interests behind it and the absence of peer-reviewed scientific evidence.

Although the two speakers emphasized different strategies–rebuilding trust, exposing organized disinformation–both pointed to a deeper issue: the deteriorating overall media environment.

Platforms such as Facebook reward emotionally charged content, Weber noted, allowing fear and anger to spread more effectively than evidence-based reporting. When Facebook blocked most Canadian news content in 2023, people’s engagement with news dropped drastically. Community Facebook groups, prone to conspiracy theories, filled the information vacuum.

Nathan pointed to climate denialism amplified through parts of the corporate media, including the National Post and other Postmedia newspapers, owned by a US hedge fund.

The decline of locally grounded, fact-based journalism is closely tied not only to the climate emergency, but also to the crisis of democracy. Both are reasons to support strong local journalism in qathet.

Robert Hackett is a member of qathet Climate Alliance.

Share this article:

Link here for more Events & Announcements or for Local Writing